REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL (RFP)
for Legal Services for FERC Relicensing of
EBMUD’s Lower Mokelumne River Project
(FERC License No. 2916).
CONTACT
Karen Donovan, Attorney
Office of General Counsel, EBMUD
(510) 287-0169
karen.donovan@ebmud.com
RESPONSE DUE
January 31, 2024
4:00 p.m.
SUBMIT ELECTRONICALLY TO
Alicia Rucobo
Office of General Counsel, EBMUD
alicia.rucobo@ebmud.com
OR
SUBMIT BY MAIL TO
RESPONSE DELIVERED BY SERVICE (UPS,
FedEx, DHL, etc.) to:
Alicia Rucobo
EBMUD–Office of General Counsel
375 11th Street, MS 904
Oakland, CA 94607
RESPONSE DELIVERED BY MAIL (USPS)
to:
Alicia Rucobo
EBMUD–Office of General Counsel
375 11th Street, MS 904
Oakland, CA 94607
REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS FOR
LEGAL ASSISTANCE RELATED TO FERC RELICENSING
OF THE LOWER MOKELUMNE RIVER PROJECT
Contact:
Response Due:
Karen Donovan, Attorney – Office of General Counsel,
EBMUD
January 31, 2024
The East Bay Municipal Utility District (District or EBMUD) Office of General Counsel,
issues this Request for Proposals (RFP) for the provision of legal services to assist the
District in the relicensing of the Lower Mokelumne River Project (FERC License No. 2916)
(Project), pursuant to the processes described by Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
(FERC) in 18 CFR Part 5. Firms or Persons responding to this RFP are referenced herein as
Proposers.
I. INTRODUCTION
EBMUD is a public utility formed under the California Municipal Utility District Act in 1923
to provide water supply to municipalities in the East San Francisco Bay Area. The District
currently serves an area covering approximately 332 square miles in Alameda and Contra
Costa Counties, supplying water to approximately 1.4 million residents. On average,
approximately 90 percent of the District’s water supply comes from the Mokelumne River.
The District’s existing Lower Mokelumne River Project (P-2916) is a multipurpose system of
surface reservoirs and aqueducts owned and operated by the District. The Project is operated
for purposes of water supply, flood control, hydropower production, and recreation.
The facilities include Pardee Dam and Powerhouse (construction completed in 1929) and
Camanche Dam and Powerhouse (construction completed in 1964). Both are owned and
operated by the District, and the District owns the surrounding lands. FERC issued a
licensing order to the District for the Project on March 10, 1981, and the license will expire
on March 31, 2031.
In the early 1990s, FERC began a proceeding to determine whether modifications to the
facilities or operations of the Project were needed for the conservation of fish and wildlife
resources. The outcome of this was a Joint Settlement Agreement between the District, the
California Department of Fish and Wildlife, and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service that was
executed in 1998. The Joint Settlement Agreement, which was subsequently included as an
amendment in the Project license, committed the District to implement new instream flows
and to undertake certain non-flow measures to protect the fishery resources of the lower
Mokelumne River.
While the District currently plans to continue its existing operations with minimal changes as
part of the relicensing, it is likely that there may be operational changes to protect and
enhance fishery resources proposed as a result of other ongoing regulatory processes.
II. SCOPE OF WORK AND SERVICES REQUIRED
The District is requesting proposals for legal services to assist with the relicensing process
with FERC. It is expected that the duties may include the following:
i. General legal advice on the hydropower relicensing process and related issues.
ii. Advice regarding the appropriate means of communicating with FERC and other
agencies during the relicensing process.
iii. Advice regarding the most effective and appropriate ways to involve and interact
with key federal and state regulatory agencies, tribes, non- governmental
organizations and other stakeholders in the relicensing process.
iv. Review of draft notices and study plans prepared by the District prior to issuance
and review of submittals from participants in the licensing process.
v. Advice on compliance with the National Historic Preservation Act, especially
Section 106 and requirements for designation and protection of historic landmarks
and structures.
vi. Assistance with developing and conducting meetings with participants in the
licensing process and negotiating and drafting of Settlement Agreements.
vii. Review of license application materials and associated documents and assistance in
developing responses to comments on documents prepared and submitted during
the process.
viii. Assistance with the preparation of associated documents, including biological
assessments and environmental studies, and assistance with the license application
and drafting of license articles and any needed post-filing documents.
III. QUALIFICATIONS
The District is seeking outside legal counsel with the following qualifications:
i. Experience providing legal services to water suppliers or public utility clients as
part of a federal hydropower licensing or relicensing proceeding with FERC,
particularly in the Western U.S. Knowledge of past, present and future trends in
FERC hydropower relicensing is essential.
ii. Expert knowledge of and experience with the Federal Power Act, 16 USC §791a et
seq., and with FERC regulations governing hydropower relicensing.
iii. Experience working on tribal consultations and tribal issues, including issues
related to tribal beneficial uses and cultural practices, in the U.S., particularly in
California or other areas of the West.
iv. Experience consulting with federal and state resource agencies and regulators in the
context of hydropower relicensing and hydropower operations, as well as water
supply planning and water rights.
v. Experience with other regulatory processes that may impact the Project relicensing
process, including but not limited to the following:
− NEPA/CEQA
− Clean Water Act 401 Certification
− Endangered Species Act
− National Historic Preservation Act
− Fish and Wildlife Coordination Act
− Wild and Scenic Rivers Act
IV. PROPOSAL CONTENT
A. Experience and Qualifications
• The District will accept proposals from individual attorneys as well as from
law firms that possess the qualifications that we are seeking. The successful
proposer must have extensive knowledge and experience in the subject areas
listed in Section III and demonstrate that it has the capability and available
staffing to perform the expected duties described in Section II.
• Proposers should describe the qualifications and experience of the specific
individuals who will provide advice under this contract. The lead attorney(s)
for the contract should also be specifically identified.
• The proposal should also identify the attorney/firm's principal place of business
and identify the location from which the attorney/firm would provide the legal
services under this contract.
• Proposers should disclose any potential or actual conflicts of interest.
"Conflict of interest" shall have the meaning as described in the relevant
California laws and the California Rules of Professional Conduct.
• The proposal should include information on the firm’s processes, policies,
and/or procedures on handling confidential and sensitive information during
and after the term of the engagement.
B. Fees
The proposal should list the hourly rates of each attorney who will provide service under this
contract, and the hourly rates of any paralegals and/or any other personnel.
C. Diversity Statement and Programs
The District is committed to creating a diverse workplace that is representative of the
community that we serve. The Office of General Counsel is interested in partnering with
counsel who are committed to creating measurable leadership opportunities for women,
minorities, LGBTQ individuals and people with disabilities. Any firm providing services to
the Office of General Counsel must be in compliance with all laws prohibiting discrimination
in employment. There shall be no discrimination against any person, or group of persons, on
account of race, color, religion, creed, national origin, ancestry, gender, including gender
identity or expression, age, marital or domestic partnership status, mental disability, physical
disability, (including HIV or AIDS), medical condition (including genetic characteristics or
cancer), genetic information, or sexual orientation.
All contractors must abide by the requirements of 41 CFR §§ 60-1.4(a). 60-300.5(a) and 60-
741.5(a). These regulations prohibit discrimination against qualified individuals based on
their status as protected veterans or individuals with disabilities and prohibit discrimination
against all individuals based on their race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender
identity, or national origin in the performance of the contract. Moreover, these regulations
require that covered contractors and subcontractors take affirmative action to employ and
advance in employment individuals without regard to race, color, religion, sex, national
origin, protected veteran status, or disability.
All proposers shall fill out and submit with the proposal the appropriate forms.
The Contract Equity Program guidelines and forms can be downloaded from the District’s
website at the following link:
https://www.ebmud.com/business-center/contract-equity-program
If you have questions regarding the Contract Equity Program, please call (510) 287-0114.
Firms will be expected to take out and maintain during the life of the agreement all insurance
required (See template Agreement, Attachment A).
V. CRITERIA FOR REVIEW
All RFPs will be evaluated by a panel of attorneys and selection will be made in accordance
with the evaluation criteria set forth in this RFP. The District reserves the right to award to a
single or multiple firms and reserves the right to reject any and all proposals and decline to